The EPA announced last Friday that it is implementing the “strongest protections in agency history” for over-the-top dicamba herbicide use on soybeans and cotton for two years. The agency’s statement said the move will support farmers and rural communities, and the decision is in direct response to advocacy from cotton and soybean farmers. The decision has drawn significant criticism from MAHA moms, including Zen Honeycutt of Moms Across America.

“Approving Dicamba is a disaster,” Honeycutt wrote. “The EPA is making Trump a liar. Trump said on his presidential platform while he was shaking Kennedy‘s hand, that he could go wild on pesticides, and he said it in the same sentence as childhood, chronic illness, and autism. We moms voted for him because of this. Over the past year, the EPA has not done one single thing to reduce our children’s exposure to toxic pesticides. Not one ban – they’ve only approved PFAS pesticides and now Dicamba. This was the wrong choice. Cotton farmers have 1000 other chemicals. We moms only need 1 vote.”

The EPA said it is committed to “gold standard science” and conducted a thorough evaluation of the data, including hundreds of peer-reviewed studies and field results. The agency said the studies involved applicators who have “decades of intensive exposure” rather than individual consumers. The agency also said there is “no unreasonable risk to human health or the environment” when OTT dicamba is applied according to label instructions. The agency release said they are concerned about dicamba drift and have applied safeguards to minimize and prevent it, including significant penalties that may include criminal charges.

Federal courts ruled twice that the EPA’s approvals of dicamba in 2020 and 2024 were unlawful. The courts ruled that the EPA understated the risks posed by drift, which can damage off-target crops and the surrounding environment. The 2024 court ruling also found procedural faults by the agency for failing to provide a proper notice-and-comment period.

A 2020 Agricultural Health Study found that herbicide applicators who had higher exposure rates to dicamba had increased risks of liver and intrahepatic bile duct cancer, chronic lymphocytic leukemia, acute/other lymphocytic leukemia, and mantle cell lymphoma. The increased incidence of liver/bile duct cancer persisted for a 20-year follow-up period, while the lung and colon cancers did not retain an increased likelihood for those with higher dicamba exposure.

The American Soybean Association, which partners with and receives funding from dicamba manufacturers, celebrated the EPA’s decision. “We appreciate EPA moving forward with a new dicamba label and recognize the importance of maintaining access to this tool for soybean farmers,” said ASA President Scott Metzger. “Farmers need clear, workable rules that accurately reflect how we farm. We look forward to reviewing the final label and hope it incorporates the feedback ASA and its state affiliates provided to ensure dicamba remains a practical option within a responsible, science-based weed management system.”

Estimates suggest that as much as 60% of processed foods contain soy or soybean oil, which is also a seed oil. The EPA has set dicamba residue tolerances for various foods and has concluded that residues within these tolerances are safe and unlikely to cause harm to consumers from non-occupational exposures.

The HighWire has reported on multiple critiques of the Trump administration’s pesticide policies and the EPA from MAHA advocates who are disappointed with some of the agency’s decisions. The Supreme Court has accepted a case from Bayer where they will consider whether people can file lawsuits in “failure to warn cases” when the label complies with EPA regulations. The Trump administration filed a brief with the Supreme Court in support of Bayer/Monsanto.

The EPA recently announced an expedited review of the human health impacts of water fluoridation while it simultaneously appeals the landmark court decision that concluded that water fluoridation poses an “unreasonable risk to human health.” While the agency could immediately begin processes to remove fluoride or reduce the recommended fluoridation levels, it is moving forward with a new review while using taxpayer dollars to appeal the court decision that requires it to act.

The HighWire also reported this week about the testing failures by the EPA that have left residents dealing with significant health effects from chemical disasters from East Palestine, OH, to Roseland, Louisiana.

The EPA also has several assistant administrators who have worked for chemical companies and lobbying groups. Douglas Troutman is the assistant administrator for the Office of Chemical Safety and Pollution Prevention (OCSPP) after serving as a lobbyist for the American Cleaning Institute, which represents BASF, Dow, and others. BASF and Bayer are two of the most prominent manufacturers of dicamba.

The OCSPP division of the EPA is responsible for regulating pesticides and includes others who have worked in lobbying and executive roles for the American Chemistry Council, which represents BASF, Bayer, and other major chemical manufacturers. Nancy Beck is the Principal Deputy Assistant Administrator at OCSPP.

Lynn Ann Dekleva was the Associate Deputy Assistant Administrator of Chemicals during the first Trump administration until January 2021. After leaving the government agency, she joined the ACC as a senior director. Kyle Kunkler is the Deputy Assistant Administrator for Pesticides in OCSPP after serving as a lobbyist with ASA, which partners with and receives funding from both BASF and Bayer.

Steven Middendorp

Steven Middendorp is an investigative journalist, musician, and teacher. He has been a freelance writer and journalist for over 20 years. More recently, he has focused on issues dealing with corruption and negligence in the judicial system. He is a homesteading hobby farmer who encourages people to grow their own food, eat locally, and care for the land that provides sustenance to the community.

Other Headlines

Coronavirus

Florida Sues Pfizer, Alleging COVID Vaccine Safety and Transmission Claims Were Deceptive

“Pfizer’s marketing campaign that drove record-breaking profits rested on deception and falsehoods,” according to a lawsuit filed by Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier against Pfizer for the way the company promoted its mRNA COVID-19 vaccine. The lawsuit alleges that Pfizer CEO Albert Bourla and the company made false and deceptive claims about the vaccine’s safety,…Continue reading Florida Sues Pfizer, Alleging COVID Vaccine Safety and Transmission Claims Were Deceptive

More news about Coronavirus

Health & Nutrition

GLP-1s for 6-Year-Olds; Trial Shows BMI Reduction and Slower Height Growth In Young Children

A Novo Nordisk-funded trial published this week in the New England Journal of Medicine and presented at ObesityWeek is being promoted as evidence that weekly semaglutide (Wegovy) can reduce BMI in children ages 6 to under 12 with obesity. The results show a 13.5% drop in BMI at 68 weeks on the drug versus a…Continue reading GLP-1s for 6-Year-Olds; Trial Shows BMI Reduction and Slower Height Growth In Young Children

More news about Health & Nutrition

Vaccines

GSK Settled  False Advertising Case About “Big Bad Wolf” Pertussis Vaccine Ads. CNN and the CDC Are Still Selling the Same Claim

Informed Consent Action Network (ICAN) helped support a lawsuit that reached a settlement in a case against GlaxoSmithKline (GSK) alleging false advertising through its “Big Bad Cough” campaign, which encouraged grandparents to get the pertussis vaccine. The ad showed a grandparent transforming into a big bad wolf character, like in “Little Red Riding Hood,” because…Continue reading GSK Settled  False Advertising Case About “Big Bad Wolf” Pertussis Vaccine Ads. CNN and the CDC Are Still Selling the Same Claim

More news about Vaccines

Science & Tech

Lawsuit Alleges Google’s Gemini “Diagnosed” a 13-Year-Old and Helped Her Plan Suicide

Google’s Gemini AI convinced a 13-year-old girl that “she was afflicted by a battery of major psychological disorders, which ultimately led [her] to believe that suicide was the only way to escape her suffering,” according to a lawsuit filed earlier this month in California. The lawsuit against Google LLC and parent company Alphabet Inc. alleges…Continue reading Lawsuit Alleges Google’s Gemini “Diagnosed” a 13-Year-Old and Helped Her Plan Suicide

More news about Science & Tech

Environment

A Nonprofit Wants to Spray 25,000 Tons of Sulfur Dioxide; It Calls That “Research,” Not Deployment

A San Francisco nonprofit called Reflective has published a plan to spray sulfur dioxide into the stratosphere, first by the ton and later by the thousands of tons, and to treat the result as a research step toward “monitored cooling” of the planet. The company said it does not advocate “deployment,” but they are advocating…Continue reading A Nonprofit Wants to Spray 25,000 Tons of Sulfur Dioxide; It Calls That “Research,” Not Deployment

More news about Environment

Policy

Trump Withdraws Heidi Overton’s FDA Nomination Amid Mifepristone Debate and MAHA Tensions

The Trump administration withdrew the nomination of Dr. Heidi Overton to lead the FDA the night before the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee was scheduled to vote on advancing her. A senior administration official told Axios that Overton “lacks the support on the Hill to move forward with her confirmation.” The same official…Continue reading Trump Withdraws Heidi Overton’s FDA Nomination Amid Mifepristone Debate and MAHA Tensions

More news about Policy